Frequently Asked Forum Questions | ||||
Search Older Posts on This Forum: Posts on Current Forum | Archived Posts | ||||
Re: Stop with your logic | |
Posted By: Ibeechu | Date: 12/28/12 11:57 p.m. |
In Response To: Re: Stop with your logic (Kermit) : I actually haven't talked to anyone who really dislikes the game. But many of : the long-time fans I talk to really dislike some aspects of it. Were it not for the Chief/Cortana stuff, I'd really, really dislike it. Well, I should qualify that. I'd really, really dislike it as a Halo game. As a game in general, I'd find it incredibly mediocre. The Chieftana stuff keeps me from saying that, though, because I thought it was the best and probably only direction the story could go with those two. : NSUSoldier has already stated my main criticism of your thesis, which was
Totally disagree. Sometimes, you really can't. Sometimes a story simply works best when you go against logic. Again, like I said in a post above, I think the trick is to make it appear logical on the surface. "Believable" is a word we throw around a lot in animation. It exists counter to "realistic." A shot doesn't ever have to be realistic so long as it's believable. If the audience can buy it, it doesn't matter at all how you got there. I've done plenty of shots where, if the camera is moved just a little bit, you can see that the movements are impossible or don't make any sense. But part of my job is to make the audience not notice and not care. And sometimes it really is a dichotomy. Sometimes I just cannot get a pose right until I break the character's elbow. I very much think the same is true for storytelling. A house can't really be lifted by only a few dozen thousand balloons, but Up makes us not even question it at all because it's set up perfectly and it's completely necessary to the story. Realistic? Logical? No way. Believable? Absolutely. And Up does not work without it. It's a necessary breaking of logic, a breaking of the elbow, for the sake of a story, and the results are breathtaking.
|
|
Replies: |
Stop with your logic | Cody Miller | 12/28/12 1:49 a.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic *SP* | Jaydee | 12/28/12 2:44 a.m. |
I.. Uhhh.... Agree...? With.... You.... | Lurono | 12/28/12 3:22 a.m. |
Also meant Adywan instead of Adi-Wan *NM* | Lurono | 12/28/12 3:26 a.m. |
Re: I.. Uhhh.... Agree...? With.... You.... | Cody Miller | 12/28/12 11:38 a.m. |
Email sent *NM* | Lurono | 12/28/12 8:56 p.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic | uberfoop | 12/28/12 3:22 a.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic *SP* | rhubarb | 12/28/12 5:39 a.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic | DEEP NNN | 12/28/12 7:43 a.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic | Metalingus627 | 12/28/12 9:43 a.m. |
I like this post. *NM* | SonofMacPhisto | 12/28/12 10:58 a.m. |
A nice hypothesis... | NsU Soldier | 12/28/12 11:05 a.m. |
Re: A nice hypothesis... | Cody Miller | 12/28/12 11:31 a.m. |
Re: A nice hypothesis... | Leisandir | 12/28/12 11:53 a.m. |
Re: A nice hypothesis... | SonofMacPhisto | 12/28/12 11:55 a.m. |
Re: A nice hypothesis... | Cody Miller | 12/28/12 12:11 p.m. |
Re: A nice hypothesis... | SonofMacPhisto | 12/28/12 5:01 p.m. |
Re: A nice hypothesis... | NsU Soldier | 12/28/12 12:19 p.m. |
This! | Chewbaccawakka | 12/28/12 12:59 p.m. |
The Loftus Approach | Leviathan | 12/28/12 11:16 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Stephen L. (SoundEffect) | 12/28/12 11:24 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | mc_leprechaun | 12/28/12 11:27 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | The Lionheart | 12/28/12 5:28 p.m. |
Qouth the Falcon, "YES!" *NM* | NsU Soldier | 12/28/12 11:33 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Cody Miller | 12/28/12 11:35 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | SonGoharotto | 12/28/12 11:38 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Stephen L. (SoundEffect) | 12/28/12 3:09 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Cody Miller | 12/28/12 3:22 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Stephen L. (SoundEffect) | 12/28/12 5:56 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Cody Miller | 12/29/12 12:47 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Cody Miller | 12/29/12 1:26 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Simpsons Rule | 12/29/12 1:56 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | uberfoop | 12/29/12 5:15 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Simpsons Rule | 12/29/12 2:49 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | uberfoop | 12/29/12 9:46 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Stephen L. (SoundEffect) | 12/29/12 9:52 p.m. |
Talking about this? *IMG* | The Lionheart | 12/30/12 4:54 p.m. |
Re: Talking about this? *IMG* | Stephen L. (SoundEffect) | 12/30/12 5:52 p.m. |
Ah, okay. | The Lionheart | 12/30/12 6:03 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Gravemind | 12/30/12 5:07 p.m. |
Thank you for this post. *NM* | The Lionheart | 12/30/12 4:15 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Ragashingo | 12/29/12 2:42 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Stephen L. (SoundEffect) | 12/29/12 11:21 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Cody Miller | 12/29/12 11:56 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Leisandir | 12/29/12 1:20 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Cody Miller | 12/29/12 3:36 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Leisandir | 12/29/12 3:38 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Stephen L. (SoundEffect) | 12/29/12 9:38 p.m. |
Same here. *NM* | The Lionheart | 12/30/12 5:01 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Stephen L. (SoundEffect) | 12/29/12 9:42 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Cody Miller | 12/30/12 11:55 a.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Stephen L. (SoundEffect) | 12/30/12 1:27 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | The Lionheart | 12/30/12 5:25 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | Archilen | 12/30/12 11:36 p.m. |
Seconded. *NM* | The Lionheart | 12/30/12 4:59 p.m. |
Re: The Loftus Approach | SonofMacPhisto | 12/28/12 5:19 p.m. |
Wow, that sounds like my kinda guy! | The Lionheart | 12/28/12 5:35 p.m. |
Agree with this also. *NM* | The Lionheart | 12/28/12 5:30 p.m. |
*applauds* You're so awesome, Levi. | Gravemind | 12/28/12 1:26 p.m. |
TOOK THE WORDS OUT OF MY MOUTH *NM* | The Lionheart | 12/28/12 5:28 p.m. |
*Salute* *NM* | Quirel | 12/28/12 5:40 p.m. |
I don't disagree, but... | SonGoharotto | 12/28/12 11:29 a.m. |
My bad | SonGoharotto | 12/28/12 11:36 a.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic | scarab | 12/28/12 12:09 p.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic | Cody Miller | 12/28/12 12:14 p.m. |
It wasn't emotionally compelling for me at all... | Phoenix_9286 | 12/28/12 1:21 p.m. |
No. | Quirel | 12/28/12 6:15 p.m. |
Very well said, sir. *NM* | Leisandir | 12/28/12 8:11 p.m. |
As always, I agree with Quirel | Ibeechu | 12/28/12 10:38 p.m. |
Re: As always, I agree with Quirel | Cody Miller | 12/29/12 1:18 a.m. |
Re: As always, I agree with Quirel | scarab | 12/29/12 5:02 a.m. |
Not quite. | Quirel | 12/30/12 3:15 a.m. |
I know this is slightly OT, but . . . . | Leisandir | 12/30/12 8:49 a.m. |
Re: I know this is slightly OT, but . . . . | Quirel | 12/30/12 1:50 p.m. |
Re: No. | TDSpiral | 12/29/12 12:09 a.m. |
Re: No. | Quirel | 12/30/12 3:33 p.m. |
Re: No. | scarab | 12/31/12 8:51 a.m. |
This is the limbo that I find myself in now. *NM* | The Lionheart | 12/30/12 4:04 p.m. |
Re: No. | Cody Miller | 12/29/12 1:04 a.m. |
Re: No. | Flynn J Taggart | 12/29/12 2:12 a.m. |
Re: No. | Quirel | 12/31/12 1:57 a.m. |
Re: No. | uberfoop | 12/31/12 4:18 a.m. |
Re: No. | RC Master | 12/31/12 8:59 a.m. |
Your brain doesn't work the same way as mine. O_o *NM* | The Lionheart | 1/1/13 5:08 p.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic | Kermit | 12/28/12 10:59 p.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic | Ibeechu | 12/28/12 11:57 p.m. |
Consistency and the Rules of Two Worlds | NsU Soldier | 12/29/12 7:06 a.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic | Leisandir | 12/29/12 9:12 a.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic | scarab | 12/29/12 9:30 a.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic | Leisandir | 12/29/12 11:08 a.m. |
Tru dat | scarab | 12/29/12 12:11 p.m. |
Re: Tru dat | Leisandir | 12/29/12 1:22 p.m. |
Re: Tru dat | Cody Miller | 12/29/12 3:37 p.m. |
Re: Tru dat | Leisandir | 12/29/12 3:39 p.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic | Kermit | 12/29/12 3:33 p.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic | Ibeechu | 12/29/12 7:32 p.m. |
Totally disagree | Avateur | 12/29/12 1:04 a.m. |
Re: Totally disagree | Stephen L. (SoundEffect) | 12/29/12 11:30 a.m. |
Re: Totally disagree | Avateur | 12/29/12 1:47 p.m. |
Re: Totally disagree | Kalamari | 12/29/12 6:44 p.m. |
It's dog food? | scarab | 12/29/12 6:55 p.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic | General Vagueness | 1/5/13 7:40 p.m. |
Re: Stop with your logic *LONG* | Dundre | 1/7/13 7:42 a.m. |
The HBO Forum Archive is maintained with WebBBS 4.33. |