In Response To: 25 Things needed in Halo 3 (b)
: Here's the list right here
: 1 combat knife
Most combat knifes are pretty poorly executed in games. I think if the weapon arsenal grows too much, it'll start to take away from the game. I like it as it is.
: 2 human fighter to match banshee
Yes. I'd love to see something human to match it, but I don't know how they would do it, since most human fighters are much larger than banshees.
: 3 chainsaw to match energy sword
A chainsaw!?!?! That is way to cliche for me.
: 4 anti personnel mines
If they could be simplified and implemented as well as fusion cores/mines already are, then fine.
: 5 anti tank mines
They already have them on containment, I don't see why they wouldn't move on to single player.
: 6 emp mines
Please.
: 7 new human rifle called Combat Rifle with bayonet and grenade launcher
Like I said, why make more superfluous weapons?
: 8 multiplayer fuel rod gun
If they could balance it, then yes. Otherwise it would already be in Halo 2.
: 9 fists
NO! I like not having to stare at some guys hands all the time, it takes me out of the game. I think they've done it well so far. Unless you throw fists from behind the screen. I think breakdown did it well.
: 10 attack helicopter
A helicopter doesn't feel Halo to me. Pelican/phantom dropships do the job fine.
: 11 air strikes
I'd wouldn't mind seeing this.
: 12 a "Sidewinder meets Blood Gulch multiplayer map"
I think its called Containment.
: 13 parachute missions
Thats what dropshock pods are for.
: 14 Machine gun with bipod
What is this, world war two? I think someone already made that game.
: 15 Jet Pack
It would be tough making it realistic, and what would be the point of a jet pack?
: 16 grenade kick move
This could be interesting.
: 17 stealth missions
I've never played a game that either, a. made stealth the major style of play and did it well, or b. made stealth a gimmick and did it horribly. I think they've added a stealth aspect with shadows and active camo already.
: 18 FLAMETHROWER
I didn't like the idea of a flamethrower in the first place, but its already been done.
: 19 four wheeler
I'd like to see a human answer to the ghost, maybe they will go through with it.
: 20 a diffrent kind of warthog for diffrent purposes (jungle, snow, etc.)
That's actually a pretty good idea. Maybe they could make a base warthog, and add different things
: 21 fully interactable and destructable enviroments
I don't think we'll see this fully in this generation.
: 22 class based multiplayer with every type of covenant and marine including
: the chief
No thanks. I like being able to switch styles and change weapons on the fly. I like knowing everybody starts the same way, and the rush to the different weapons.
: 23 4 player Co-op
Doesn't everybody want this?
: 24 the ability to give orders
I like the simplicity of Halo games, how would they keep this simple? Maybe if you could command NPCs to change styles of combat... offense/defense, aggressive, etc...
: 25 MOST IMPORTANTLY other spartans. in the third book he finds his team and
: all of thim except for 4 die
I wanna know where they are too.
You've got some good ideas, and then you have some ideas where you're just trying to turn it into battlefield or other shooters.
| 
